Performance Appraisal of Supervisors


Performance Appraisal of Supervisors

Performance grading form

Name                           
Department
Evaluation Period
Overall Rating



Goal Specific to the Individual Supervisor

A.   Extent of achievements

B.   Areas for improvement

Future Goal

A.   Goal objective

B.   Resources and support required


Please tick where appropriate where 1=Very Good, 2=Good, 3=Fair, 4=Unknown


1
2
3
4
Leadership/Accountability/Ownership (20%)




Delegates duties and responsibilities appropriately




Honest and ethical in all entrusted responsibilities




Takes personal responsibility for the success of the unit




Unit consistently meets all the performance indicators




Communication (20%)




Demonstrates active listening skills




Demonstrates good facilitation skills




Easily accessible to all staff




Encourages open exchange of ideas




Holds timely, fair, and constructive performance appraisals




Organizes regular unit meetings




Shares information with management and staff




Respectful Employee Relations (10%)




Provides respectful, constructive feedback




Treats everyone respectfully




Values diverse perspectives




Collaboration (10%)




Facilitates exhaustive discussion before decision-making




Seeks consensus when appropriate




Develops strong teamwork in the unit




Conflict Resolution (10%)




Resolves conflicts quickly and fairly leading to positive outcomes




Effectively solves daily routine problems




Employee Advancement (10%)




Encourages employee advancement through suitable training and development




Encourages and supports staff participation in various project teams




Diversity Support (10%)




Supports advancement of a multicultural team




Participates and facilitates staff participation in diversity training opportunities




Provides enabling environment for multicultural workforce




Promotes affirmative action for minorities




Health and Safety (10%)




Ensures a safe working environment






Rationale

A supervisor primarily has authority over a small group of workers and is in charge of their workplace. The supervisor has the power and authority to give instructions and or orders to subordinates of whom they are held responsible for their work and actions. Hence, the main role of the supervisor is communication and leadership, as reflected in the performance grading form weighting, with both those roles contributing 40% of the overall total supervisor rating.

The supervisor’s main responsibility is to ensure that the group of workers achieves an assigned amount of production within allocated deadlines and to required levels of quality, costs and safety. For the group of workers to perform well together, they must be in synch; with the supervisor performing a leading role. This requires certain qualities such as good people skills, supportiveness and fairness. Such qualities will lead to the unit having respectful employee relations (10), good collaboration (10%), and effective conflict resolution (10%).

Through direct daily employee contact, supervisors are uniquely placed to respond to employee needs, problems, and satisfaction. A direct link between the management and the workforce, they should be at the forefront in employee advancement (10%), diversity support (10%) and health and safety (10%).

These weighted broad areas that reflect the supervisor’s duties, responsibilities and qualities are further broken down to specific performance  indicators, with each of them being graded from very good to unknown (poor) in the performance grading form. The form also appraises whether the supervisor met their overall goal and sets a new goal for them.



References

Falcone, P, and Tan, W, 2013. The Performance Appraisal Tool Kit: Redesigning Your Performance Review Template to Drive Individual and Organizational Change. New York: AMACOM.

Grote, D, 2011. How to Be Good at Performance Appraisals: Simple, Effective, Done Right. New York: Harvard Business Review Press.

Neal, JE, 2014. Effective Phrases for Performance Appraisals: A Guide to Successful Evaluations. Perrysburg: Neal Publications.

Comments